Supreme Court of The Virgin Islands November 26, 1985, Probate No. 84/1985 (In re the Estate of Cummings)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-11-1985

CHRISTIAN, Senior Sitting Judge

OPINION AND ORDER

Before the Court are three petitions, the first filed by Robert S. Cummings, surviving spouse of the deceased and one of the two executors and trustees of her estate named in her Last Will and Testament, dated November 9, 1967 (hereafter “Cummings”), praying the Court to admit the Will of the deceased to probate and record as written, but replacing Paul Gitlin (hereafter “Gitlin”), the other executor and trustee so named, by Mr. Hein Christensen (hereafter “Christensen”), notwithstanding the fact that the Testatrix so named Gitlin and also named the Morgan Guaranty Trust Company of New York as the substitute just in case either Cummings or Gitlin at any time and for any reason failed to qualify to discharge the functions of either office; a second petition filed by Gitlin to admit the Will to probate and record and grant him Letters Testamentary and of Trusteeship as co-Executor and co-Trustee of the Estate; and a third petition, joined in by both Cummings and Gitlin, to appoint a special administrator, pursuant to 15 V.I.C., Section 238, to protect the es*594tate from waste or loss, in case the appointment and qualification of the permanent fiduciaries is unduly delayed. For the reasons appearing below, that portion of the petition of Cummings praying the Court to replace Gitlin with Christensen is denied; in all other respects, the petition of Cummings is granted; the petition of Gitlin is granted in all respects; and the joint petition [sic] to appoint a special administrator is denied.

I. FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Katharine Brace Cummings made her Last Will and Testament dated November 9, 1967. At that time both sides agree she was a well-to-do woman, cultured, educated, in good health. In making her Will, the deceased used the legal services of Gitlin, who by 1967 had been an old member of the law firm of Ernst, Cane, Berner & Gitlin, which represented Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Inc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.