Newport News County Circuit Court November 18, 1985, Case No. (Law) 9445-FB (Sovran Bank, N.A. v. Forman)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-11-1985
By JUDGE FRED W. BATEMAN
The above-styled suit relates to a party wall agreement dated April 24, 1919, between F. B. Longan et al. and C. F. Hundley, wherein Longan, owner of the Hotel Pocahontas (34th and Washington Avenue), granted unto Hundley the right to use, in common, a portion (not to exceed 32 feet from the ground) of a brick wall located on the north side of the said hotel which was situated on Lot 22, Block 239 (Plat Book 1, page 3) with a caveat that Hundley would use due care and diligence in using said wall to support rafters in the construction of a proposed building so as not to injure or damage the wall aforesaid. The plaintiffs are successors in interest to Longan and the defendants are successors in interest to Hundley.
The building that was formerly Hotel Pocahontas deteriorated and the owners, under threat of condemnation by the City of Newport News, demolished the structure in 1983, leaving a party wall for the defendant with the south side (formerly the interior side of the hotel wall) exposed.
The bricks comprising the exposed wall were manufactured at the time of the construction of the hotel and their consistency is of a density and texture that absorbs moisture. The City of Newport News, by virtue of its building code, seeks to protect the exposed wall by requiring the sealing, parging and painting thereof.
*269The plaintiffs, by declaratory judgment, seek to determine whether the plaintiffs or the defendants are responsible for the costs that will be incurred to comply with the City building code. The defendants, in their answer and grounds of defense, allege that the demolition was performed in a negligent manner. The essence of the alleged negligence is that the plaintiffs left the party wall, which remained after demolition, in a condition that is not up to the standard of the building code of the City of Newport News, which incorporates the BOCA Code.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit