Fairfax County Circuit Court May 6, 1985, Case No. (Law) 67670 (Messer v. Shannon & Luchs Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-05-1985
By JUDGE JOHANNA L. FITZPATRICK
This matter comes before me on Defendants’ Demurrer. After hearing argument of counsel and reviewing the pleadings submitted to the Court, it is my decision that the Demurrer be overruled as to Counts I and II and sustained as to Count III of Plaintiff’s Motion for Judgment.
Count I of the Motion for Judgment alleges a breach of the Virginia Consumer Protection Act. Virginia Code Section 59.1-198(A) defines a "consumer transaction" as the "advertisement, sale, lease, or offering for sale or lease of goods or services . . . and (ii) transactions involving purchase money loans made by lenders . . . ." Real estate is included as "goods" under Section 59.1-198QB). Virginia Code Section 59.1-198(C) defines a supplier as "... a seller or lessor ... or a manufacturer or distributor . ..." In a companion case to the case at bar, Judge Brown has held that a real estate agent is analogous to a distributor.1 I concur with Judge Brown’s determination as to this point. Lastly, the Virginia Consumer Protection Act applies to acts performed by a *19supplier in connection with a consumer transaction. The transaction that is the subject of this litigation is therefore covered by the Act. The Demurrer to Count I is overruled.
Count II alleges fraud on the part of Defendant, incorporating paragraphs 1 through 55 by reference. I am satisfied that the allegations contained in paragraph 1 through 61 are sufficient to support Plaintiff’s claim. The facts are set forth with sufficient precision to apprise Defendants of the character of Plaintiff’s charges so that they might shape their defenses accordingly. Tuscarora v. BVA, 218 Va. 849 (1978), citing, Alsop v Catlett, 97 Va. 364 (1899). Defendants’ Demurrer to Count II is overruled.
Count III of the Motion for Judgment seeks to assert a private cause of action for the unauthorized practice of law.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit