District Court, D. Puerto Rico January 21, 1985, Civ. No. 78-2327 HL (Diaz v. Becton Dickinson & Co., S.A.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-01-1985

OPINION AND ORDER

LAFFITTE, District Judge.

This matter is before us on motions for summary judgment filed by defendants, requesting dismissal of the complaint on the grounds that this Court lacks in personam jurisdiction over them.

Plaintiffs allege in their amended complaint filed on May 28, 1980, that they have suffered physical and mental damages due to mercury intoxication resulting from the negligence of all defendants in the operation of a thermometer manufacturing plant at Juncos, Puerto Rico. Defendants Becton Dickinson & Co. of New Jersey (BD) is the parent company of Becton Dickinson & Co., S.A. (BDSA), a Panamanian corporation doing business in Puerto Rico, as well as of all subsidiaries organized under the trade name Beeton-Dickinson. Codefendants Farleigh S. Dickinson, Jr., Henry F. Becton, and Wesley J. Howe were, during specific time intervals, members of the Board of Directors of Becton Dickinson, Becton Dickinson, S.A., and Becton Dickinson Puerto Rico, Inc. (BDPR). Also, codefendants Wesley J. Howe and Marvin A. Asnes, Henry Supplee, Robert G. Butler,1 and Benedict Harter acted as officers of BDPR, which employed the plaintiffs herein. The Hartford Insurance Company allegedly insures all defendants.

On October 2, 1979, and May 19, 1980, respectively, codefendants Howe, Harter, Asnes, Supplee, Butler, BD, and BDSA moved to dismiss the previous complaint.2 In view of the amended complaint filed on May 28, 1980, the above mentioned defendants filed, on June 3, 1980, a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction adopting by reference their previous motions.3 On December 29, 1980, plaintiffs filed a second amended complaint adding as defendants Insurance Company of North America and Aetna Casualty & Surety Company. By order entered on March 9, 1982, the complaint was dismissed as to these two last defendants.

On January 12, 1982, BDSA moved for summary judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.