District Court, N.D. Illinois December 9, 1985, No. 80 C 5124 (United States v. Board of Education)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-12-1985

MEMORANDUM ORDER

ASPEN, District Judge:

In this Memorandum Order we resolve the issues raised by the parties concerning the Remedial Order and the 1985 Bilingual Transition Funds. In compliance with the request in our October 15,1985 opinion, the parties have worked out an agreement as to much of the structure of the Remedial Order. We discuss below primarily what was not agreed upon.

*843A. The Remedial Order

After carefully reviewing the Board’s proposed Remedial Order and the parties’ comments, the Court endorses the general format of the proposed order. In addition, except for the amendments discussed below, the Court adopts the Board’s proposed order as written. As described later, the Board shall prepare a revised Remedial Order for our signature.

1. Paragraphs l(i) and l(j)

The United States’ objections to paragraphs l(i) and l(j) are overruled, with one minor qualification. The Board is correct that the United States failed to give appropriate priority consideration in FY 1983, and that the Yates Bill did not discharge the United States’ duties for that year. At the same time, the United States is correct that the Yates appropriation counts for something, although it is somewhat disingenuous for the Executive Branch to rest on this laurel when it vigorously opposed the Yates Bill and acted in bad faith by doing so. Nevertheless, the Remedial Order’s declarations should reflect that at least the Legislative Branch of the United States provided funds in 1983, and that the Executive Branch obeyed Congress’ order to provide' those funds directly to the Board. Accordingly, 11 l(i) should be amended by inserting in the last line, following “fiscal 1983,” “except for the amount appropriated for and provided to the Board under the so-called ‘Yates Bill.’ ”

As for ¶ l(j), we disagree with the United States that the rhetoric is “excessive.” The complete record of the case more than adequately supports that declaration.

2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.