Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit January 24, 1985, Appeal No. 84-1261 (Textron, Inc. v. U.S. International Trade Commission)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-01-1985
CO WEN, Senior Circuit Judge.
Textron, Inc. (Textron) appeals from an International Trade Commission (ITC or Commission) determination that no violation of section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930 took place in the importation from Taiwan of vertical' milling machines, parts, accessories, and attachments thereto by certain firms. Specifically, Textron claims that the ITC erred in determining that it had no common law trademark in the external ap*1021pearance of the Bridgeport Series I vertical milling machine or any portion thereof, that its asserted mark was not infringed, and that the domestic industry had not been substantially injured by those acts found to be unfair. Por the reasons set forth, we affirm.
I.
The subject matter of this case — the Bridgeport Series I vertical milling machine — is pictured herein, with its component parts labeled.
*1022It is a metal cutting machine manufactured by Textron, used to produce machined surfaces on metal by means of rotary milling cutters. It weighs approximately one ton and sells for about $6,000. The original Bridgeport vertical milling machine (similar in appearance to the present model) was designed in 1938, with a significantly different configuration from those designs then existing on the market. A number of changes have been made in the design of the machine since that time, but its general external appearance has remained essentially the same since the 1950’s.
The Bridgeport machine achieved remarkable success almost immediately after its introduction, and has held a dominant position in the vertical milling machine market for many years. The Bridgeport Series I has long been generally regarded as the standard for its size and weight in the machine tool industry — so much so that vertical milling machines of its size are often referred to as “Bridgeport-type” machines. The word “Bridgeport” has long been a federally registered trademark, and it appears prominently in bold script on the head and ram of the machine.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit