Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit September 18, 1985, No. 84-1942 (Old Dominion Power Co. v. Donovan)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-09-1985

K.K. HALL, Circuit Judge:

Old Dominion Power Company (“Old Dominion”) petitions this Court to review and set aside the final decision of the Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission (the “Commission”), holding: (1) that Old Dominion was an independent contractor and an “operator” within the meaning of the Federal Coal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1977, 30 U.S.C. §§ 801 et seq. (the “Mine Act”); (2) that Old Dominion breached Mine Safety and Health Administration (“MSHA”) regulations when one of its employees was electrocuted on mine property; (3) that the issuance of a citation to Old Dominion one year after the incident was reasonably prompt; and (4) that a civil penalty of $1,000 was appropriate.1 We reverse.

I.

On January 22, 1980, James Harlow was electrocuted at an electrical substation near a coal mine in southwestern Virginia. Harlow was employed by Old Dominion, an electric utility serving southwestern Virginia.

Westmoreland Coal Company (“West-moreland”) leases the property where the fatality occurred, and has contracted with Elro Coal Corporation (“Elro”) to operate the mine on the property. The substation is located on the property adjacent to a mine-access road and is segregated by a locked, chain link fence. Westmoreland built and owns the substation. It is composed of transformers, meters, power lines, and utility poles. Westmoreland purchases high-voltage power from Old Dominion and transmits it to the substation, which reduces the voltage to a lower voltage suitable for use by Elro in its mining operations. The only facilities owned by Old Dominion at the substation are those needed by the utility to determine how much electricity Westmoreland has purchased.

The sole revenue derived by Old Dominion from its relationship with Westmore-land is for the sale of electric power. Old Dominion does not perform any maintenance at the substation, or of the transmission or distribution lines leading to and from the substation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.