District Court, District of Columbia April 25, 1985, Civ. A. No. 83-1495 (Coyne v. Grupo Industrial Trieme, S.A. de C.V.)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-04-1985
MEMORANDUM
GESELL, District Judge.
This case was filed on May 25, 1988 and dismissed without prejudice on June 16, 1983 pursuant to a settlement agreement filed with the stipulation of dismissal. On plaintiffs motion, opposed by the defendants, the Court on March 12, 1985 vacated the dismissal, reinstated the suit, and ordered the defendants to show cause why judgment should not be entered against them for the amount they agreed to pay in the settlement agreement. The case is now before the Court on the parties’ pleadings filed in response to that Order.
Defendants are a Mexican corporation and its board chairman and chief executive officer, Miguel Guajardo, a citizen of Mexico. Plaintiff, a Washington, D.C. financier, sued defendants for allegedly breaching various aspects of an agreement whereby plaintiff loaned money to and invested in defendants’ soft drink bottling plants in Mexico. Plaintiff moved to reinstate this action after an alleged breach of the settlement agreement.1
In opposing judgment on the settlement agreement, defendants primarily urge that service of process on defendants must be quashed because defendant Guajardo was enticed to the District of Columbia for the purpose of serving him. Plaintiff contends there was no fraudulent enticement and that defendants waived any objection to service by entering the settlement agreement.
Defendants properly asserted the defense of insufficiency of service in their first responsive pleading in this case, their response to the Court’s show-cause order of March 12, 1985. See Fed.R.Civ.Pro. 12(b), 12(h)(1). Defendants were not required to assert the defense in the stipulation of dismissal or at any time thereafter until the action was reinstated. Therefore no waiver occurred, and the defense was timely raised.
In their opposing sworn affidavits recounting the service of process in this case, plaintiff and defendant Guajardo continue to dispute each other’s version of the facts.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit