Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Warren County February 4, 1985, no. 315 of 1984 (Commonwealth v. Murtha)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-02-1985

WOLFE, P.J.,

Defendant has been charged with the crimes of robbery, making false reports to law enforcement authorities, fleeing or attempting to elude police officers, and violation of the Motor Vehicle Code involving damage to attended vehicle or property and failure to stop and render aid.

Defendant asserts he is a drug abuser and has applied for disposition of the charges in lieu of trial or criminal punishment under the “Controlled Substance, Drug, Device, and Cosmetic Act” of April 14, 1972, P.L. 233, §18, 35 P.S. §780-118. This section provides if a person is charged with a non-violent crime and claims to be a drug dependent or a drug abuser he may, prior to trial, request appropriate treatment under the Mental Health and Mental Retardation Act of 1966 in lieu of criminal prosecution. Procedurely defendant must submit to a physician experienced or trained in the field of drug dependency or drug abuse and if the diagnosis of the physician and recommendations be that treatment and rehabilitation would be preferable to the criminal charges, the charges may be held in abeyance or withdrawn in order to institute treatment for drug dependency or, if the physician recommends to the *556contrary, the criminal charges are brought to prosecution.

The act gives the sole discretion to the government attorney, to-wit, the district attorney, to exercise his discretion whether or not to accept the physician’s recommendation. If the district attorney does not accept the physician’s recommendation, he is obligated to so state in writing and furnish defendant with a copy of his decision and reasons therefore.

Upon defendant’s application the court appointed William M. Mann, Jr., M.D., to examine defendant in accordance with the provisions of the act. Dr. Mann reported in writing his diagnosis that defendant has an alcohol dependence, continuous; cannabis dependence, continuous; cocaine abuse, unspecified; and other mixed substance abuse, in remission.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.