Court of Appeals of Oregon February 12, 1986, 7013; CA A31451 (Gifford v. Western Aviation Insurance Group)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-02-1986

*647

WARDEN, J.

Defendants Duncanson and Holt Aerospace Managers Agency, Inc. (Aerospace) and Security Insurance Company of Hartford (Security) appeal from a judgment dismissing their cross-claims against their agent, defendant Western Aviation Insurance Group (Western), before trial.

1

Although a number of issues were discussed in the briefs, at oral argument the parties narrowed the case to one issue: whether the cross-claim of Aerospace and Security had stated a claim in negligence against Western. We reverse and remand.

Plaintiff sought insurance coverage for his aircraft through defendant Western, an insurance broker. Western obtained the coverage from defendant Security.

2

The binder plaintiff received contained no exclusion for Alaska travel; however, the policy Security later issued had an attached endorsement purporting to exclude coverage for Alaska travel and to provide coverage for passengers. Security had not filed this form of endorsement with the Insurance Commissioner as mandated by ORS 743.006(1). The plane crashed in Alaska, killing the pilot and two passengers. Security relied on the exclusion and denied coverage for the loss of the aircraft.

We will recount the procedural history of the case only to the extent that it is relevant to this appeal. The trial court granted plaintiff Gifford’s motion for judgment on the pleadings against Security on the first count of his second amended complaint, which alleged breach of contract. The court, in an order dated October 6, 1982, relied on both grounds propounded by plaintiff: (1) that ORS 743.075(1) estopped Security from asserting the Alaska exclusion, because it was not included in the binder; and (2) that Security did not comply with the filing requirement of ORS 743.006(1), thereby rendering the Alaska exclusion void. Security moved for reconsideration or for a new trial. While the motion was pending, Security and plaintiff reached a settlement, pursuant to which they filed two stipulations.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.