Court of Appeals of Minnesota May 6, 1986, C8-85-2257 (McGregor v. Commissioner of Public Safety)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-05-1986

OPINION

POPOVICH, Chief Judge.

Respondent was arrested for driving while under the influence and took an In-toxilyzer test, which produced a result of .11. The Commissioner of Public Safety revoked his driving privileges, and respondent petitioned for judicial review. The trial court rescinded the revocation. The Commissioner appeals. We affirm.

FACTS

Officer Kristine Arneson stopped respondent Richard Allan McGregor for speeding.

*340

She observed indicia of intoxication, administered several field sobriety tests, and placed him under arrest for driving while under the influence of alcohol. Arneson read respondent the implied consent advisory and offered him a breath test, which he agreed to take. She then drove him to the Scott County Jail.

Arneson testified she observed respondent for 15 minutes prior to the test, sitting at her desk, while respondent sat in a chair in front of her. She filled out police reports and acknowledged while she was writing she was not able to observe respondent. Arneson said she watched for his reactions, how he sat, what his eyes looked like, and what he said. However, she testified she did not know the specific purpose of the 15 minute observation period, had no training, was not told what she was supposed to watch for during the 15 minute period, but said she did not observe anything unusual.

Officer Larry Williams, a certified Intoxi-lyzer operator, administered the test to respondent. He did not participate in the 15 minute observation period. On the Intoxi-lyzer record form, in the “remarks” section, he indicated he checked respondent’s mouth. The Intoxilyzer test produced a reported value of .11.

The Commissioner revoked respondent’s driving privileges for failing the test. The trial court rescinded the revocation and the Commissioner appeals.

ISSUE

Did the trial court err in concluding the Intoxilyzer test was not valid and reliable?

ANALYSIS

Respondent challenged the validity of the test result.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.