United States Court of International Trade December 17, 1986, Court 83-4-00593 (Deringer v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-12-1986

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

DiCARLO, Judge:

The questions presented in this action are whether reverse osmosis maple sap concentrators are filtering and purifying machinery and apparatus for liquids as classified by the United States Customs Service (Customs) under item 661.95, Tariff Schedules of the United States (TSUS) dutiable at 4.9% ad valorem, and whether such articles are more properly classified for entry duty-free as sugar-making machinery, or parts thereof, under item 666.20, TSUS, or alternatively as agricultural or horticultural implements not specially provided for under item 666.00, TSUS. The Court finds that the merchandise is filtering and purifying machinery and apparatus for liquids and that it must be classified under item 661.95, TSUS, even if also described under items 666.20, TSUS or 666.-00, TSUS.

From the stipulations and evidence submitted at trial, the Court finds that the reverse osmosis maple sap concentrators are designed and marketed specifically for use by maple syrup producers to decrease the time required to remove water from raw maple sap. The water is removed by reverse osmosis whereby the raw sap, which is clear and has the consistency of water, contacts under pressure a reverse osmosis membrane. A major portion of the water in the sap passes through the membrane and is recovered as a “permeate” stream, while the sap that cannot pass through is collected as a “concentrate” stream. The concentrate is further “dewatered” by the process of evaporation in a conventional maple sap evaporator which utilizes heat. Only after the application of heat is the resulting sap suitable for sale and consumption as maple syrup.

Plaintiff asserts that the merchandise is not classifiable as filtering and purifying machinery and apparatus for liquids, since it neither filters nor purifies but rather concentrates the sap by a dewatering process.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.