Supreme Court of Louisiana November 24, 1986, 85-C-1008 (Vuskovich v. Thorne)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-11-1986

498 So.2d 1072 (1986) Joseph S. VUSKOVICH v. Geraldine V. THORNE, Executrix of the Succession of Vincent Vuskovich, et al. No. 85-C-1008. Supreme Court of Louisiana. November 24, 1986. *1073 Roy M. Bowes, Gretna, Mack E. Barham, Robert E. Arceneaux, Barham & Churchill, New Orleans, for defendant-applicants. Peter Butler, Aubrey Hirsch, Jr., M. Shawn McMurray, Butler, Heebe & Hirsch, New Orleans, for plaintiff-respondent. LEMMON, Justice.[*] This is an action for partition by licitation of Lot C-7 of Oakdale Subdivision in Jefferson Parish. The lot sought to be partitioned is one of several lots subdivided from the Vuskovich family estate and is presently owned in two equal proportions by Joseph Vuskovich and by the succession of Joseph's deceased brother. The principal issues include (1) whether La.C.C. Art. 1303, which prohibits partition under certain circumstances, is applicable directly or by analogy, and (2) whether Joseph's right of partition between co-owners should be denied on the basis of his alleged abuse of right or breach of fiduciary duty as trustee of the trust established by his brother. Facts Lot C-7 and the surrounding lots are shown on the following map: *1074 In 1970, Visko's, Inc., a corporation whose stock was owned by Joseph and Vincent Vuskovich, opened a seafood restaurant in the building on Lot C-7. In 1974, a fire destroyed the building on Lot C-7. The two brothers purchased the lot in their individual names and built a new building. In 1975, the two brothers leased the lot and building to Visko's, Inc. for operation of a restaurant. The ten-year lease contained an option to purchase at any time during the term of the lease at "CAB value". Since the building covered almost the entirety of Lot C-7, Visko's, Inc. provided parking for the restaurant customers on Lot C-9, which was owned by MATO-V Enterprise, Inc. (MATO-V), a corporation whose stock was owned entirely by the Vuskovich family. However, Visko's, Inc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.