North Dakota Supreme Court July 30, 1986, Civ. 11151 (Priel v. R.E.D., Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-07-1986

MESCHKE, Justice.

Marvel Priel appealed from a district court judgment entered on a jury verdict in favor of R.E.D., Inc. (Burger King),

1

and William Collins, Inc. (Collins).

2

We reverse and remand.

On January 11, 1982, Priel fell on an accumulation of snow and ice and fractured her right leg as she stepped from the side

*67

walk to the parking lot of a Burger King restaurant. Burger King employees were instructed to push snow from the sidewalk to the parking lot. Collins was employed to remove snow from the parking lot, but was not expected to get closer to the curb than six inches.

On August 18, 1983, Priel fell again and injured her left hip. Priel’s treating physician testified that this fall was caused by instability of Priel’s right knee resulting from the earlier fall at Burger King.

Priel sued Burger King for damages, alleging negligence and nuisance. Burger King filed a third-party complaint against Collins. The trial court refused to submit instructions on Priel’s nuisance theory. The jury returned a special verdict in which it found: (1) that Burger King was negligent; (2) that Burger King’s negligence was not a proximate cause of the injury to Priel; and (3) that Collins was not negligent. Judgment was entered accordingly.

In her appeal, Priel has raised issues about improper argument of counsel for Burger King, the trial court’s failure to give a requested instruction, the jury’s finding of negligence but not proximate cause, and the trial court’s failure to submit Priel’s theory of nuisance to the jury.

In his closing argument to the jury, Alden Gjevre, counsel for Burger King, said: “We are talking about money that my client will have to pay out of his own pocket.” The following colloquy then occurred between the court and counsel:

“MR. IRVINE [counsel for Priel]: ... I’m aware of the real party in interest statute and the need to keep the issue of insurance out of the proceedings, but what Mr. Gjevre said is simply not true.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.