Supreme Court of Alabama September 26, 1986, 85-520 (Sullivan v. Walther Builders, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-09-1986

The plaintiff homeowners appeal from the trial court's granting of a motion for summary judgment for Walther Builders, Inc., and former officers of the corporation. In 1979, Lawrence and Margaret Oldemoppen filed an action against Walther Builders, Inc., and its president, William Walther, claiming damages for breach of contract, alleging faulty construction of their house. The case was tried, and the jury returned a verdict for the Oldemoppens. In 1980, Walther Builders filed an action against John and Helen Sullivan to enforce a materialman's lien, arising from the construction of the Sullivans' house. The Sullivans counterclaimed for damages resulting from faulty construction of the house and for assault and battery by William Walther against Mrs. Sullivan; Mr. Walther was brought in as a third-party defendant. The jury returned a verdict for Walther Builders on the construction claim and for Mrs. Sullivan on the assault and battery claim. On January 28, 1982, the Sullivans, the Oldemoppens, and David and Gloria McWatters filed this action against Walther Builders; William Walther and his wife Carolyn Walther, who was the secretary-treasurer of the corporation; and several organizations associated with the promotion of homeowner warranties. The complaint alleged breach of contract, fraud, concealment, and conspiracy in the marketing of 10-year homeowner warranties. On January 29, 1985, Walther Builders and Carolyn Walther filed a motion for summary judgment on the claims by the Sullivans and the Oldemoppens, stating that the present action was barred by the prior judgments on the faulty construction claims. Carolyn Walther supported the motion with an affidavit, which included lists of deficiencies drawn up by the Sullivans and the Oldemoppens and offered for use in the prior cases. On the lists, the couples had noted that the defendants had failed to provide the 10-year homeowner warranties allegedly promised to them.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.