United States Bankruptcy Appellate Panel for the Ninth Circuit August 14, 1986, Bankruptcy App. Panel No. OR-86-1168-MeEAs, Bankruptcy No. 385-01707 (Sievers v. Green (In Re Green))
Also known as
United States · · · 14-08-1986
MEYERS, Bankruptcy Judge:
This appeal raises the question of whether a trial court is required, as a matter of law, to dismiss a Chapter 13 case after the Debtors defaulted on scheduled payments. We conclude that no such requirement exists and AFFIRM.
Linda Sievers entered into a land sale contract with Gary Walter Randolph Green and Jenelle L. Green (“Debtors”), wherein Sievers was to receive $102,000 payable in monthly installments. After the Debtors fell behind in these payments, they filed a Chapter 13 petition. Immediately after confirmation of their Chapter 13 plan, the Debtors fell behind in their scheduled payments. Sievers filed a motion under Sections 1307(c)(4) and (6) to dismiss or convert for failure to make these payments.
The trial court found that the Debtors were in default under the plan. However, the trial court also found that this default was immaterial, declaring that the motion to dismiss was premature.
An analysis of the language of Section 1307(c) leads to the inevitable conclusion that the decision to dismiss a Chapter 13 is a
discretionary decision
of the trial court. Section 1307(c) states that upon request of a party in interest a court may convert a Chapter 13 case to Chapter 7 or
*531
dismiss for cause. The word “may” is a permissive word, not a word of command.
In re Benediktsson,
34 B.R. 349, 350 (W.Wash.1983). By contrast, Section 1307(b) states that upon the request of a debtor at any time, the court “shall” dismiss a Chapter 13 case. The word “shall” is a word of command which allows the trial court no discretion.
Matter of Hearn,
18 B.R. 605, 606 (D.Neb.1982);
In re Benediktsson, supra,
34 B.R. at 350. This gives the debtor an absolute right to dismiss.
In re Nash,
765 F.2d 1410, 1413 (9th Cir.1985). A creditor has no such automatic right.
In deciding whether to dismiss a Chapter 13 case at the request of a creditor, the trial court’s discretion is to be guided by the factors listed in Section 1307(c).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit