Massachusetts Appeals Court June 20, 1986 (MacCuish v. Volkswagenwerk A. G.)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-06-1986

Dreben, J.

On March 17, 1980, fifteen year old Karen MacCuish, a passenger in a Volkswagen van, died of a fractured skull. Her father, as administrator of her estate, brought a wrongful death action (G. L. c. 229, § 2) against the defendant Volkswagen companies. A jury awarded the plaintiff $3,000,000 on theories of negligence and breach of warranty. In answer to special questions, the jury did not find gross negligence or wilful or reckless conduct on the part of the defendants and, accordingly, denied the plaintiff punitive damages under G. L. c. 229, § 2. The defendants raise numerous questions in this appeal. Except for the rate governing prejudgment interest and the method of reducing the verdict because of a prior settlement, we affirm the judgment.

The van (a 1975 “microbus”), after a collision with a 1975 Toyota Célica, ended up on a sidewalk on its left side. Karen was found lying on her back with her head partially outside the van’s middle side window.

The experts offered different explanations as to how the van reached its ultimate landing place. The defendants’ experts claimed a violent “slamdown”; the plaintiff’s, that the van took a lazy roll after tipping when its rear wheel climbed a lawn berm. A crucial and bitterly contested question was whether the middle window of the van remained in place and only shattered when the side of the van hit the ground, or whether

*383

the window had fallen out earlier. It was undisputed that the fatality rate in automobile accidents is far higher when a person is ejected from a vehicle

2

and, for this reason, both sides laid great stress on whether Karen’s head came out of the window prior to impact.

The plaintiff presented two main design defects leading to Karen’s injuries — the van’s window retention system and its seat mounting system. As to each, the defendants argue that the plaintiff’s theory was speculative and lacked a reasonable factual basis,

see Nass

v.

Duxbury,

327 Mass.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.