California Court of Appeal April 2, 1986, E001791 (Williams v. Braslow)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-04-1986
Opinion
McDANIEL, J.
The appeal here is from a summary judgment entered in favor of defendant County of Riverside (defendant county), owner and operator of the Riverside County General Hospital. The judgment dismissed plaintiff’s action, as to defendant county, brought for her personal injuries resulting from medical malpractice allegedly committed by various persons also alleged to have been employees of defendant county.
One of the theories upon which the motion was pursued, one which proved to be decisive, was that whereas the
proposed claim,
prepared on plaintiff’s behalf pursuant to the Tort Claims Act, designated Dr. Braslow as “the public employee causing the claimant’s injury,” the undisputed fact was that Dr. Braslow had never been an employee of defendant county.
Apparently relying on this pivotal showing, the trial court granted the motion, there being no issue of fact on this point which provided the defendant county, according to its argument, a complete defense to plaintiff’s action, based as it was on a respondeat superior theory. However, the de
*765
limiting rule, relied upon by the court, is subject to a saving exception which it did not take into account. Accordingly, the court’s ruling and judgment based thereon will be reversed with directions.
Background Facts
Plaintiff underwent surgery known as “gastric partitioning” performed by defendant Dr. Braslow at Riverside General Hospital, with defendant Dr. Nelson and defendant Dr. Neilson attending and assisting in a manner not disclosed by the record. The initial surgery was performed on or about April 6, 1981. Before that date, plaintiff, who was suffering from “morbid obesity,” consulted a Dr. Stevens about treatment for her depression brought on by this condition. After consultation with Dr. Stevens, plaintiff was referred to Dr. Braslow and conferred with him in his office at Parkview Hospital.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit