California Court of Appeal February 3, 1986, A028705 (In Re Marriage of Downes)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-02-1986

Opinion

KING, J.

J(1) In this case we hold that when a motion is made pursuant to Civil Code section 5124 to award the moving party a community interest in a military pension awarded to the other party as his separate property in a stipulated judgment of dissolution which has become final, and there is a factual conflict whether the parties bargained to eliminate this risk as part of entering into their settlement agreement, the court must conduct an evidentiary hearing and resolve this factual issue before it can act on the motion.

Kenneth L. Downes, Jr., appeals from an order granting Norma Jean Downes’ motion for modification of their 1982 dissolution decree which had awarded Kenneth’s military retirement to him as his separate property. The order modifying the decree awarded Norma a community interest in Kenneth’s military pension. We reverse and remand for an evidentiary hearing.

The parties separated in 1981 after 30 years of marriage. During their marriage, Kenneth acquired the right to a military pension payable upon his retirement.

The parties stipulated to an interlocutory judgment of dissolution on May 13, 1982. The separate property section of the dissolution decree states “The parties hereby stipulate, and the Court approves and confirms, the following to be their separate property: [|] Husband: U.S. Navy Retirement and Veteran’s Benefits [1] Wife: California State Public Employees’ Retirement System Benefits from employment at San Jose State University.”

At the time the parties obtained their interlocutory judgment of dissolution, the authority of California courts to divide community interests in military pensions was in flux. On June 25, 1981, the United States Supreme Court had held interests in military pensions could not be treated as marital property by the states, based upon its interpretation of congressional intent in enacting applicable federal statutes, under the supremacy clause of the United States Constitution.

(McCarty

v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.