Texas Court of Appeals, 13th District October 30, 1986, 13-86-138-CV (Mistletoe Express Service v. Sanchez)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-10-1986
OPINION
KENNEDY, Justice.
Appellee Sanchez brought suit for damages for lost goods. The trial court entered judgment against appellant for $11,-443.95, plus attorney’s fees and prejudgment interest. Appellant, Mistletoe Express, brought third party actions against appellees Villarreal and Axton, which resulted in take-nothing judgments. Appellant raises five points of error. We affirm the judgment of the trial court.
Sanchez, a resident of Mexico, bought a new computer system in El Paso and sent the computer to Mary Bossom in Brownsville. Bossom was told to hold the computer for Sanchez. Instead of driving to Brownsville to pick up the computer as Sanchez originally planned, he directed Bossom to ship the computer to San Antonio. From there, Sanchez’s friend, Sende-jas, was to fly back to Mexico with the computer. Bossom delivered the computer to Mistletoe Express, paid the shipping costs, and designated Arturo Villarreal as the consignee on the bill of lading. Villarreal, a stranger to Sanchez, was an associate of Sendejas. The bill of lading shows Villarreal’s address as 7700 Broadway, yet Mistletoe Express delivered the computer to 7701 Broadway. Appellee Axton, who works in the building at 7701 Broadway, signed for the package. Axton is not an associate or agent of Villarreal.
Axton eventually located Villarreal and informed him of the computer’s arrival at 7701 Broadway. However, this was approximately a week after its expected arrival and Sendejas had already departed for Mexico. Villarreal walked across the street and identified the computer, but refused to take delivery of the computer. Mistletoe Express was informed of Villarreal’s refusal to take delivery, and was directed to return for the computer. It is not clear whether it was Axton or Villarreal that informed Mistletoe Express of Villarreal’s refusal to accept delivery. When Mistletoe Express returned to 7701 Broadway for the computer, it was gone. Axton claims a delivery man picked it up.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit