Missouri Court of Appeals July 29, 1986, 50358 (Points v. Dzur)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-07-1986
SMITH, Judge.
Plaintiff appeals from a verdict and judgment against him in a wrongful death action allegedly arising from medical malpractice. We affirm.
Plaintiff’s submitted negligence against both doctors was based upon their failure to provide “necessary and proper care and treatment” for plaintiff’s mother’s myocardial infarction and cardiac condition. The verdict director additionally charged defendant Dzur with failing to correctly interpret an EKG of plaintiff’s mother. The two verdict directors were MAI 19.01 modified to include as the “Fourth” paragraph the language “such negligence directly caused or directly contributed to cause the death of” plaintiff’s mother. Both defendants conversed the respective verdict directors by hypothesizing a verdict for the
*635
doctor unless the jury believed that doctor to be negligent and “as a direct result of such negligence” plaintiffs mother died. Neither converse utilized the “directly contributed to” language of the verdict director. In
Brickner v. Normandy Osteopathic Hospital, Inc.,
687 S.W.2d 910 (Mo.App. en banc 1985) we held such omission from the converse instruction to be reversible error. Defendants admit the converse instructions were, under
Brickner,
erroneous.
Until fairly recently any variation from MAI was deemed to be prejudicial unless the party offering the instruction could demonstrate the absence of prejudice.
Conger v. Queen City Food & Vending, Inc.,
591 S.W.2d 161 (Mo.App.1979) [1, 2];
McGowan v. Hoffman,
609 S.W.2d 160 (Mo.App.1980) [2]. Rule 70.03 provides that objections are not required to he made at the time of trial in order to preserve error for appellate review. This rule and the presumption of prejudice from variations of MAI had led the bench and bar to believe that counsel could safely make no objections at the instruction conference and be fully protected in regard to instructional error on appeal.
This protection began to wane in
Hudson v. Carr,
668 S.W.2d 68 (Mo.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit