New York Court of Appeals January 14, 1986 (Cruz v. American Export Lines, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-01-1986

OPINION OF THE COURT

Per Curiam.

The central issue in these cases involving claims under the Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act (the Act) (33 USC §§ 901-950) is whether the Joint Maritime Safety Code (the Code), prepared jointly by shippers and the long

*6

shoremen’s union, has expanded the duties imposed upon shipowners under the Act. We hold that it does not.

I

Francesco Cruz, a longshoreman employed by John W. McGrath Corporation, a stevedore company, was injured on September 17, 1976 when a hi-lo being used by longshoremen to move bales of burlap struck a piece of dunnage, dislodging a 2,400 pound burlap bag that struck him on the back of his foot. He commenced this action against American Export Lines, Inc. and Farrell Lines, Inc., the owners of

Export Builder,

the vessel being discharged of its cargo by McGrath longshoremen at the time of the accident. Cruz alleged that the "stevedoring work on board [the

Export Builder]

was being performed under the general supervision and direction of defendant^]”, that hatch No. 3, where the work was being done, was "maintained, supplied and provided” by defendants and that defendants, through their negligence,

inter alla,

in failing to provide a safe place to work "violated the provisions of the Joint Maritime Safety Code of the Port of New York”.

Following joinder of issue and completion of plaintiff’s examination before trial, the shipowners moved for summary judgment contending that no legally sufficient cause of action against them had been set forth. The motion was based on Cruz’s deposition testimony that at the time of the accident the cargo operations had been turned over to the stevedore company, which defendants argued was an independent contractor employing acknowledged experts in cargo handling who chose the manner and method of discharging the cargo.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.