Department of Justice Office of Legal Counsel December 5, 1986 (Application of Fourth Amendment to Use of Electronic Beeper in Tracking Bank Robbery Bait Money)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-1986

AppflncaMIlntfy ©ff Founirillh AmnKenndinnieiiiilt to ui§® o f ElecHrcwmSc

B eep ers nnn TracCdmg Bamk E&olblfoeiry Band Mouney

The w arrantless m onitoring by law enforcem ent personnel of electronic beepers hidden in bait

money robbed from a bank probably does not constitute a “search” implicating the Fourth

Am endm ent, even after the beeper being monitored has been taken into a home.

One w ho has com e into possession o f beeper-m onitored bank bait money by robbing a bank has

no legitim ate expectation of privacy in such m oney that would be violated by the beeper

m onitoring.

A lthough this form o f beeper monitoring probably does not constitute a search implicating the

Fourth A m endm ent, it was recommended that the FBI should continue its practice of seeking

a w arrant w hen that form of m onitoring is undertaken. However, because exigent circum ­

stances justify the F B I's practice o f com m encing beeper m onitoring immediately when a

baited bank is robbed, the FBI is not constitutionally required to refrain from monitoring the

beeper until it has obtained a warrant.

December 5, 1986

M em orandum O p in io n f o r t h e A s s is t a n t D ir e c t o r , L e g a l C o u n s e l ,

F edera l B ureau of In v e s t i g a t i o n

This memorandum responds to your request for an opinion on the legality of

the warrantless monitoring of beepers hidden in bank robbery bait money. This

Office has concluded that such monitoring probably does not constitute a

“search,” even after a beeper has been taken into a home. Nevertheless, we

recognize that a court subsequently may disagree with this interpretation of the

Fourth Amendment. We therefore recommend that the FBI continue its current

practice of seeking a warrant in every case.1

Before proceeding further, it is important to emphasize the narrow scope of

the constitutional issue presented.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.