Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit January 31, 1986, 84-3451 (Jesse F. McWilliams v. Texaco, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-01-1986

JOHN R. BROWN, Circuit Judge:

In this appeal, a seaman complains of three errors in the trial of his Jones Act

1

negligence suit: (1) the submission of the case to the jury by a general, rather than a special verdict; (2) the improper grant of a directed verdict as to the rate at which he was entitled to receive maintenance; and, (3)the entry of a directed verdict against his claim for punitive damages for his employer’s allegedly willful refusal to pay maintenance.

*516

Although we reject as without merit the seaman’s contentions regarding the form of the verdict and his entitlement to punitive damages, we hold that the trial court erred in limiting proof of the maintenance issue to only that evidence which related to the seaman’s actual expenses during the maintenance-cure period. We therefore reverse and remand on that issue.

A Sailor’s Life for Me

Jesse McWilliams was a seaman for over thirty-five years. The last sixteen years of his seafaring life were spent exclusively aboard vessels owned by Texaco, Inc., primarily aboard the oil tanker S.S. TEXACO NEW JERSEY. Over the course of three years,

2

McWilliams was involved in a series of four mishaps that allegedly caused him injury. After the last of his accidents, McWilliams disembarked from the TEXACO NEW JERSEY and never again returned to sea. He alleged that the accidents resulted from Texaco’s negligence, and filed suit seeking damages under the Jones Act and for unseaworthiness under the general maritime law.

At trial, McWilliams introduced evidence on the issue of his employer’s liability, and also attempted to introduce evidence relating to his claim for maintenance. On the maintenance issue, however, the trial court permitted him to introduce only that evidence which related to the actual expenditures he incurred while convalescing in his hometown of Pineapple, Alabama.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.