Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit January 17, 1986, 85-1501 (Kenneth C. Elmore v. Chicago & Illinois Midland Railway Company)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-01-1986
POSNER, Circuit Judge.
Kenneth Elmore, who was fired by the Chicago & Illinois Midland Railway for unauthorized moonlighting, asks us to reverse the judgment of the district court dismissing for lack of jurisdiction his petition to review a decision of the National
*95
Railroad Adjustment Board upholding his firing.
The facts, somewhat simplified, are as follows. Elmore requested and was granted permission to take a personal day of leave on May 31,1979. During that day he was seen doing roofing work on someone’s house (not his own). On June 1 the railroad sent Elmore a letter notifying him, pursuant to Rule 32 of the collective bargaining contract, which requires notice and an opportunity for a hearing before' a dismissal, that there would be a hearing to decide whether he had violated Rules P and W of the agreement. These rules provide that “Employees must not absent themselves from their duties ... without proper authority” and that “Employees will not be permitted to engage in other employment without permission of their employing officer.”
The hearing was held on June 19 before an employee of the railroad. Elmore was represented by a union griever. The railroad’s chief of police testified that he had seen Elmore repairing the roof. Elmore admitted that he had done some roofing work on the afternoon of his day off, May 31.
On June 29 the railroad fired Elmore for having violated Rule 15(c) of the collective bargaining agreement, which provides that “An employee absent on leave, who engages in other employment will forfeit all seniority rights, unless special arrangements shall have been made in writing____” On July 3 the hearing officer rendered her decision, finding that Elmore had indeed violated Rules P and W but imposing no sanction, since Elmore had been fired.
Elmore complained to the National Railroad Adjustment Board (see 45 U.S.C.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit