Court of Appeals for the First Circuit March 6, 1986, 85-1671 (Clayton M. Bryant v. George A. Vose, Jr., Superintendent of Massachusetts Correctional Institution)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-03-1986

COFFIN, Circuit Judge.

Appellant, Clayton M. Bryant, asks us to reverse dismissal of his writ of habeas corpus. He claims two errors of constitutional dimension in his Massachusetts murder trial: admission of an involuntary oral confession made without the benefit of

Miranda

warnings, along with its “fruit”, a subsequent written confession, and ineffective assistance of counsel. We reject both of these claims, and affirm dismissal of the writ.

I.

Background

The facts of this case

are

set forth comprehensively in the opinion of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 390 Mass. 729, 459 N.E.2d 792 (1984), and we therefore only summarize the facts as found by that court.

1

On November 21, 1978, William Seduski was shot in the chest with a sixteen-gauge shotgun at his home. Appellant was known to have disliked the victim, at least in part because Seduski was involved in a steady relationship with Jane McNeal, who operated a restaurant near appellant’s home. Appellant, a steady customer of the restaurant, was in love with McNeal, was fond of her children, and wanted to marry her.

Appellant was questioned on the day after the murder by the state police lieutenant in charge of the homicide investigation, and was given

Miranda

warnings at that time. The defendant voluntarily spoke with the officer but denied that he was involved in the murder. At some point during the next month, when appellant and the lieutenant met briefly on the street, the officer asked appellant if they could meet again to discuss the shooting. Appellant agreed. On February 2, 1979, the town’s new police chief, who previously had been introduced to appellant, arrived at appellant’s home at 5 p.m. pursuant to an appointment to speak with appellant. The chief, who had just come off duty, was in uniform and carrying a gun.

*366

Appellant invited the chief into his house, offered him a cup of coffee, and the two men spoke for a few minutes.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.