Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit May 8, 1986, 85-1570 (Local Beauty Supply, Inc. v. Lamaur Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-05-1986
CUMMINGS, Chief Judge.
Plaintiff appeals from the summary judgment granted to defendant. The district court held that plaintiff lacked standing to bring this antitrust action against the defendant. We affirm on the ground that the plaintiff has failed to demonstrate an antitrust injury and therefore cannot obtain damages or an injunction.
I. STATEMENT OF CASE AND FACTS
The defendant, Lamaur Inc., is a Minneapolis, Minnesota, manufacturer of beauty products. Lamaur has approximately 150 authorized distributors who sell the products as either full-service or cash-and-carry operations. Full-service dealers maintain field salespersons to advertise and sell the products to beauty salons. Cash-and-carry dealers typically sell the products through flyer advertising and sell primarily to small salons, retailers or unauthorized distributors. Lamaur prefers the full-service dealers because they provide more services to the clients and invest in advertising and active promotion of Lamaur’s product. The plaintiff, Local Beauty Supply (Local), was a distributor of Lamaur products from 1956 to September 19, 1980, with its principal place of business in Castleton, Indiana. Over that time Local became more and more a cash-and-carry operation.
In 1973 Lamaur entered into a Lamaur distributor agreement (LDA) with its dealers. The agreement contained three pertinent provisions. First, the distributors agreed not to sell restricted-use products (such as permanent waves and bleaches) to non-salon customers without consent from Lamaur. Second, the agreement provided that distributors who failed to provide full service and advertising would remit to Lamaur 15% of the wholesale price as a functional discount. Third, the distributors agreed to submit to auditing by Lamaur in order to ensure compliance with the previous two provisions. If a distributor breached the agreement, Lamaur could cancel the LDA without prior notice. Local was a signatory to both the 1973 and 1977 LDA’s.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit