Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit May 8, 1986, 85-5513 (Richard T. Gilpin and Ruth Gilpin, His Wife v. Alyssa E. Langan)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-05-1986

combined-opinion

789 F.2d 1034 Richard T. GILPIN and Ruth Gilpin, his wife, Appellees, v. Alyssa E. LANGAN, Appellant. No. 85-5513. United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit. Argued Feb. 18, 1986. Decided May 8, 1986. James M. Scanlon, (Argued), Scanlon, Howley, Scanlon & Doherty, Scranton, Pa., for appellant. David A. Howell, (Argued), Clarks Summit, Pa., for appellees. Before: WEIS and SLOVITER, Circuit Judges, and POLLAK,* District Judge. OPINION OF THE COURT WEIS, Circuit Judge. 1 In this diversity personal injury case, the district court granted a directed verdict for plaintiff on the question of liability. As the driver of one of two automobiles involved in a head to head collision, the plaintiff's conduct would be a matter for consideration under the state's comparative negligence statute. We conclude that the issue of the plaintiff's possible negligence should have been submitted to the jury. Accordingly, we will vacate a judgment for plaintiff and remand for a new trial. 2 After entry of the directed verdict, the jury returned a damage award of $225,000. Motions for a new trial or remittitur were denied, and defendant appealed. 3 The factual scenario is an uncomplicated one involving a center of the road automobile collision on Route 307, a two-lane macadam road in rural Wyoming County, Pennsylvania. The accident occurred on April 9, 1982 at approximately 12:10 A.M. The road surface was dry, but there was some snow on the berm. 4 Plaintiff Richard Gilpin testified that he was alone in his automobile driving south.1 As he approached a narrow bridge about fifteen feet in length, Gilpin first saw the defendant's auto northbound on the same road. At that sighting, the defendant's vehicle was about 300 feet away and travelling in its proper lane. When the two cars were approximately 200 feet apart, Gilpin noticed that the other car was crossing into his lane. He braked, but the left fronts of the two vehicles collided on the bridge.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.