Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit May 21, 1986, 85-5657 (The Southland Corporation, a Texas Corporation v. Emerald Oil Company, Etc., and Charles E. Thomas Company)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-05-1986
ALARCON, Circuit Judge:
Plaintiff/appellant The Southland Corporation (hereinafter Southland) appeals in part from a judgment that defendants/ap-pellees Jack Smith, Emerald Oil, Inc. (hereinafter Emerald), Jerry Thomas, and Charles E. Thomas Company (hereinafter CTC) are not liable for fraud and conversion and Thomas and CTC are liable only for nominal damages for trespass. South-land contends on appeal on that the district court erred in concluding that: (1) a lease agreement between Southland and Emerald did not provide for transfer of ownership of gasoline dispensing equipment installed on the leasehold; and (2) even if the lease did provide for transfer of ownership, there was no transfer of title in fact under the California Commercial Code. We reverse the district court’s interpretation of the lease agreement because it is our view that the lease did provide for transfer of ownership and there was a transfer of title in fact.
FACTS
On September 23, 1982, Southland leased a gasoline station in Torrance, California to Emerald. A month later Emerald entered into a contract of sale with CTC for gasoline dispensing equipment which was to be installed at the Torrance station. CTC installed the replacement equipment on October 21, 1982, and billed Emerald for $55,-000 on 30 days credit for the equipment.
On November 10, 1982, Southland and Emerald executed an amendment to the Torrance lease. The amendment permitted Emerald to install the gasoline dispensing equipment purchased from CTC, and reduced Emerald’s rent for the Torrance station by $500 per month effective upon installation.
During January and February of 1983, Emerald paid CTC approximately $27,500 for the replacement equipment. In May, 1983, Emerald abandoned the Torrance premises.
In June, 1983, employees of CTC entered the Torrance station and removed some parts of the replacement equipment.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit