Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit May 8, 1986, Appeal 85-2607 (Milton Hodosh and Richardson-Vicks, Inc. v. Block Drug Company, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-05-1986

ORDER

MARKEY, Chief Judge.

On April 21, 1986, appellee (Block) filed a “Motion to Vacate and For Sanctions”, requesting that this court’s decision of March 24,1986, 786 F.2d 1136, be vacated, that the appeal be reconsidered by a new panel, and that appellant (RVI) be sanctioned at least by denial of its costs on the appeal. The motion is without foundation and borders on the frivolous.

During the pendency of the appeal, RVI was acquired by Proctor and Gamble, Inc. Though counsel accuse each other of knowing and failing to promptly announce that event, the controlling fact is that the Certificate of Interest filed by RVI in accord with this court’s Rule 8 was not amended and the acquisition of RVI was not brought to the attention of this court, or to the attention of any judge of this court, by anyone, until weeks after the decision was handed down.

The appeal was heard and decided by a panel consisting of Circuit Judges Rich, Davis, and Baldwin. The opinion for the court was authored by Judge Rich, whose spouse has a financial interest in Proctor and Gamble. There is no way in which Judge Rich could possibly have known that Proctor and Gamble was in any manner involved in the appeal, and Block nowhere asserts such knowledge. Promptly upon learning of the acquisition, Judge Rich recused himself from any further involvement in the case.

Block bases its motion on allegations of “impropriety” and “appearance of impropriety” because the appeal “was heard by a panel including Judge Rich who was statutorily disqualified from participation.” The allegations are without merit. The statute, 28 U.S.C. § 455, expressly provides that a judge is disqualified when he

knows

that his spouse has a financial interest in a party. Thus, there was no basis for disqualification, and neither an impropriety nor appearance of impropriety, as Block should have known from a reading of the plain language of the statute.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.