Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit July 25, 1986, 85-1624 (United States v. Richard L. Hunt)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-07-1986

GEE, Circuit Judge:

Today, we consider a criminal defendant’s challenges to various instructions given to the jury. On appeal, he argues that, taken together, the trial court’s refusals to adopt his requested instructions amount to a denial of his right to a fair trial. Disagreeing, we affirm his convictions.

The facts of this case are undisputed. In 1983, Mary Tubbs, Susan Maddox, and appellant Richard Hunt formed two Texas companies, Creditsaver, Inc. and First Se

*1097

curity Credit. With the stated corporate purpose of providing “mail order information service,” they advertised in such publications as The National Enquirer and The Star Classified. Their advertisements provided the following:

Assured credit: MasterCard, Visa, and more. All available through First Security Credit regardless of past credit, no credit, bankruptcy; completely guaranteed. Women and students cards available.

The ads included a toll-free number; a phone call would result in a solicitation letter and an application mailed to the hapless customer. The letter’s solicitation read “Dear Future Cardholder” and was signed by “David Weston, New Accounts Department.”

1

It encouraged the customer to fill out the application and return it along with a check for 35 dollars. The application itself requested information concerning employment and income, just as actual credit card applications would.

The complying customer would receive no credit card, however; rather, he would receive only a seven page booklet entitled “Ten Easy Steps to Good Credit.” No advertisement or brochure had mentioned anything about such a booklet, and several customers later testified that the ads led them to expect the delivery of actual credit cards. Those calling the company to complain reached only an answering service. Their complaints, however, eventually reached the United States Postal Service, whose investigation eventually led to the seizure of the companies’ business records and to criminal indictments.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.