Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit July 11, 1986, 85-2282, 85-2283 (United States v. Mark Spudic and Rutilo Ochoa)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-07-1986

HARLINGTON WOOD, Jr., Circuit Judge.

This case arises from a twenty-seven count indictment returned on January 17, 1985, charging seven defendants

1

with various crimes growing out of their business or procuring and marketing stolen motor vehicles in interstate commerce,

2

their specialty being vans and pickup trucks. Only two of the defendants, Ochoa and Spudic, are involved in this appeal after being found guilty in a jury trial.

3

Spudic complains that the counts charging interstate transportation of a stolen motor vehicle and the counts charging concealment of the same motor vehicle are multiplicitous; that the evidence is insufficient; that no offense of mail fraud was stated; and that the sentencing process was flawed because the trial judge made use of a “sentencing commission” composed of a number of probation officers from which the defendants and their attorneys were excluded.

Ochoa likewise questions the sufficiency of the evidence denying that he was a member of the charged conspiracy. Instead, he claims, he was involved only and separately with Arturo Garcia, a government informant which, he says, could not constitute a conspiracy.

*1337

It can at least be said for Spudic and Ochoa that they were not the conspiracy’s top executives. The executives were John and Manuel Salazar, and Kenneth Huff. After the stolen vehicles were acquired they were stored in various locations where they could be adapted for the stolen vehicle market by the installation of false vehicle identification number (“VIN”) plates and a change of ignition and door locks. The coconspirators assisted in various ways by obtaining the stolen vehicles, doing the identification conversions, procuring the documentation, and delivering to buyers.

Both defendants attack their conspiracy convictions, but from slightly different angles. Ochoa sees in the evidence only multiple conspiracies, not one, and claims that he was not and could not be a part of any of them.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.