Circuit Court for the Judicial Circuits of Florida September 10, 1986, Case No. 85-245 AC (Consolidated) (State v. Gendreau)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-09-1986

*157OPINION OF THE COURT

MASTOS, Judge.

The State of Florida, appellant in seven of the eight cases consolidated herein, appeals from a Motion to Suppress granted by the trial court. In essence, the trial court held that the failure to keep a running log for the field testing device, known as the Indium Crimper, did not constitute substantial compliance with Health and Rehabilitative Service Rule 10D-42.24(14)(a). This rule sets out what information is required to maintain a log book.

It should be noted that HRS Chapter 10D-42, entitled Implied Consent, contains various rules and regulations promulgated to implement, inter aha, Florida Statutes 316.1932, 316.1933 and 316.1934. These rules and regulations are intended to govern the collection and chemical testing of breath and/or blood samples for alcohol content.

In holding that the failure to maintain per $e a log book on the Indium Crimper device violates the above cited HRS rule, the trial court, through its order of suppression, has blocked admissibility of the breathalyzer reading in all of the consolidated drunk driving cases pending before this court. Accordingly, the State of Florida seeks a reversal of the lower court’s order.

It is undisputed between the parties that a log book which complies with the applicable HRS rules and regulations governing the chemical testing of breath samples was kept and maintained on the machine which performed the actual chemical analysis of the breath sample. The reliability of the test results obtained during the actual chemical analysis was, in addition, not in issue in the lower court.

What is in issue, then, is the rather narrow question of whether the same log book requirements governing the machine which chemically analyzes the breath sample should also apply to the Indium Crimper device which encapsulates the breáth sample which, in turn, is later chemically analyzed by a separate and distinct laboratory’ process. We think not.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.