Missouri Court of Appeals July 29, 1986, WD 37494 (Snapp v. Ryder)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-07-1986

LOWENSTEIN, Judge.

Defendants Mary Ann and Alfred Ryder appeal from an adverse jury verdict and judgment rendered in favor of plaintiff Richard Snapp. Snapp sued in quantum meruit for payment due on custom farm work he allegedly performed in 1981 and 1982 on the Ryders’ land located in Sullivan County. The Ryders counterclaimed, alleging Snapp failed to perform the 1981 work as agreed. The jury found for Snapp both on his claim and on the counterclaim. The counterclaim is not involved in this appeal.

The questions on appeal involve the prejudicial effect of evidence admitted concerning the Ryders’ nonpayment of a soybean seed bill and plain error review of the trial court’s allowing the jury to award interest on the judgment from the date of demand.

On appeal the evidence is viewed in the light most favorable to the prevailing party. Hunter v. Norton, 412 S.W.2d 163, 165 (Mo.1967). In 1981, Snapp did custom farming for the Ryders. He submitted a bill to the Ryders in January, 1982 and received payment of $15,320. Snapp did not include combining he was currently engaged in when he submitted this bill.

Later in 1982, Mary Ann Ryder authorized Snapp to do additional custom farming. In 1983, Snapp submitted another bill to the Ryders for $22,432, itemized as follows:

500 acres of 1981 com combined $ 9,000.00

60 acres of 1981 beans combined 1,080.00

490 acres 1982 discing 2,940.00

490 acres of 1982 second discing 2,940.00

490 acres 1982 planting 2,450.00

490 acres 1982 field cultivating 2,940.00

184 acres 1982 cultivating 920.00

27 acres chisel plowing 162.00

TOTAL $22,432.00

The Ryders already had paid $15,000 toward satisfaction of this bill, leaving a balance owing of $7,432. Added to this amount was $4,534 for additional combining, hauling, and plowing. Thus the total. *631amount owed by the Ryders to Snapp was $11,966.

The cause was submitted in quantum meruit for labor and services. The jury returned a verdict in the amount of $11,-150.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.