Missouri Court of Appeals December 23, 1986, No. 51087 (State v. Turner)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-12-1986

CRIST, Judge.

Defendant appeals from a jury conviction of robbery in the first degree. He was sentenced to life imprisonment as a persistent and dangerous offender. We affirm.

Defendant was charged with robbery in the first degree and armed criminal action. He, and a companion, robbed the owners of Lincord Rexall Drug Store with the aid of what one owner described as an object appearing to be a real gun. The only thing the owners could see was what appeared to be a gun barrel sticking out with the rest of the gun covered by defendant’s clasped hands. The jury acquitted defendant on the armed criminal action charge.

*528Defendant claims the conviction on the robbery count and the acquittal on the armed criminal action count was inherently inconsistent, and was the result of the jury’s failure to be convinced of appellant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

The robbery conviction required jury findings that the defendant (1) took property, (2) threatened the immediate use of physical force, and (3) displayed or threatened the use of what appeared to be a deadly weapon or dangerous instrument. In order to convict defendant of the additional armed criminal action charge, the jury had to find defendant used a deadly weapon. It chose not to do so, apparently believing defendant perpetrated the robbery by using what appeared to be a deadly weapon. There was no inconsistency in the verdicts since the jury did not believe beyond a reasonable doubt defendant had a real gun. In any event, defendant has no cause to complain about the jury failing to believe one element of the State’s case.

Defendant finds fault with the trial court’s refusal to grant a mistrial when one of the victim-owners referred to a photograph of defendant as a “mug shot.” When coupled with a police detective’s testimony the photograph was taken in 1983, defendant insists this effectively informed the jury defendant had been arrested in 1983.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.