Colorado Court of Appeals March 13, 1986, No. 85CA0220 (Columbine Beverage Co. v. Continental Can Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-03-1986

ENOCH, Chief Judge.

Plaintiff, Columbine Beverage Company (Columbine), appeals from a judgment entered against Western National Bank of Denver as garnishee for interest in the amount of $6440 claimed by defendant, Continental Can Company, Inc. (Continental). We reverse.

In June of 1980, Columbine, as lessee, brought an action seeking declaratory relief against Continental, as lessor, for determination of liability for sales taxes incident to a long term equipment lease executed by the parties. In December of 1981, the trial court found in favor of Continental and ordered Columbine to reimburse Continental for applicable taxes Continental had paid in the amount of $30,552.76, plus “interest from the date of invoice against ... Columbine.” Columbine subsequently appealed to this court, which affirmed the judgment. Columbine Beverage Co. v. Continental Can Co., 662 P.2d 1094 (Colo.App.1982).

In May of 1983, Columbine paid Continental $48,216.40, representing the principal amount owed plus interest at the statutory rate under § 5-12-102, C.R.S. (1985 Cum.Supp.) from the date of Continental’s shipping invoices to Columbine. Continental thereafter caused a writ of garnishment to be served upon Western National Bank of Denver (garnishee) in the amount of $6440, representing the difference between interest calculated at the statutory rate and the higher rate designated in Continental’s shipping invoices.

In January of 1985, the trial court denied Columbine’s motion to quash the writ, and entered judgment against the garnishee in favor of Continental for the amount claimed. Relying on § 4-2-207(2), C.R.S., of the Uniform Commercial Code, the court found that the higher invoice interest rate was an additional term that had become part of the original lease agreement between the parties. The court construed its original award of “interest from the date of invoice against ...

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.