New York Court of Appeals May 1, 1986 (Koenig v. Jewish Child Care Ass'n)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-05-1986

OPINION OF THE COURT

Memorandum.

The order should be affirmed, with costs.

On the particular facts and circumstances presented we agree with the Appellate Division that respondent association occupies the subject apartment as a residential tenant as the lease, itself, provides; that an entity can be a residential tenant under the Rent Stabilization Law; that the apartment is, therefore, subject to the Rent Stabilization Law; and that because petitioner does not meet the requirements of the Code of the Rent Stabilization Association of New York City, Inc. § 54 (A) he is not entitled to a judgment evicting respondent. The issue discussed in the dissent — whether respondent occupies the apartment as a primary tenant — is not before us in this holdover eviction proceeding. The dissent refers to cases where the Conciliation and Appeals Board had made primary residency determinations (see, Rent Stabilization Code § 54 [E] [1], [2], [3]). No such determination has been made here.

Titone, J. (dissenting). Although a group home undoubtedly performs a vital and beneficial service to the public, I cannot accept the notion that it comes within the ambit of the rent stabilization laws, and, therefore, dissent.

The Jewish Child Care Association of New York City (JCCA), a not-for-profit corporation, has operated a group home for adolescent girls in an eight-room apartment located *958on West End Avenue in Manhattan since 1955. The apartment was decontrolled in 1968, and its last lease, which expired June 30, 1977, permitted occupancy by up to 10 persons, including at least one adult, at a monthly rental of $490.26.

A cooperative plan became effective in 1977, but JCCA did not bring suit to challenge it, and the shares allocated to the apartment were conveyed to petitioner Jerome Koenig who commenced this holdover proceeding to evict JCCA.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.