New York Supreme Court February 13, 1986 (Dumain v. Carey)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-02-1986

OPINION OF THE COURT

Melvyn Tanenbaum, J.

This motion by defendants and cross motion by plaintiffs each seeking summary judgment (motion No. 14,599) and the motion by plaintiffs for leave to serve a supplemental complaint and cross motion by defendants for leave to serve an amended answer (motion No. 9,770) are consolidated in the interest of judicial economy and are determined as follows:

In this action pursuant to State Finance Law article 7-A, plaintiffs in their capacity as citizens and taxpayers of the State of New York and as members of the Board of Education of Huntington Union Free School District seek injunctive relief and a judgment declaring that (1) Education Law § 3602 is unconstitutional and contrary to statute to the extent that it provides for formulas in the calculation of State aid to school districts predicated upon inaccurate data not subject to verification and (2) plaintiffs are entitled to retroactive and *222continuing adjustment of State aid provided to them upon the basis of such inaccurate data.

The alleged misappropriations arise from a series of legislative enactments between 1977 and 1982 beginning with a direction that the State Tax Commission provide a space on the State income tax return form for taxpayers to indicate the school district of their residence (L 1977, ch 309). Subsequently, by amendments to Education Law § 3602, the formulas for distribution of Low-Income Supplemental School Aid (LISSA) (L 1980, ch 53) and second-tier operating aid payments (L1981, ch 53) were established which included as a major factor in each formula the gross income of the residents of each district. Pursuant to the mandate contained in Education Law § 3602 (20) (b) (since repealed by L 1985, ch 53, § 46), the State Tax Commission adopted regulations necessary to calculate such income data (20 NYCRR part 2000). 20 NYCRR 2000.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.