New York Supreme Court April 3, 1986 (Carbery v. Carbery)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-04-1986
OPINION OF THE COURT
Theodore A. Kelly, J.
This is a proceeding to annul the results of an election held in the Village of Pomona on March 18, 1986 and for a new election to elect a Mayor and two trustees.
Petitioner Joseph Carbery is the incumbent Mayor of the Village of Pomona. Petitioner Bob Wallack and respondent Ronald Rothberg (Rothberg) are incumbent trustees. Their respective terms of office expire on April 6, 1986 and each of them was a candidate for reelection on March 18, 1986.
Parties opposed to their reelection organized a write-in campaign on behalf of respondents Melvin Klingher (Klingher), Herbert Marshall (Marshall) and Alvin Appell (Appell). About one hour before the polls closed, the only voting machine broke down. Voters were then permitted to write the names of candidates on slips of paper which were dropped into an open cardboard box.
The canvass of the vote taken at the election showed the following result:
*729Mayor Line 1
Klingher 169
Carbery 167
1st Trustee
Marshall 175
Klingher 17
Appell 1
Wallack 165
2nd Trustee (2) Line 3
Appell 166
Marshall 15
Elaine Adler 1
Rothberg 169
On March 18, 1986 the candidates requested the Rockland County Board of Elections (the Board) to recanvass and determine the validity of the votes cast at the election. The Board conducted the recanvass on March 21, 1986. On March 25, 1986 the Board reported the following tabulation to the clerk.
Machine Ballot Box Total
Mayor: Joseph Carbery 147 19 166
Melvin Klingher 132 38 170
Trustee: Bob Wallack 148 16 164
Ronald Rothberg 151 17 168
Herbert Marshall 130 54 184
Alvin Appell 121 35 156
The Board, however, refused to certify that any candidate had been elected to any position.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit