New York Supreme Court April 16, 1986 (Cronin v. Cronin)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-04-1986
OPINION OF THE COURT
Vincent R. Balletta, Jr., J.
Motion by the defendant for leave to amend his answers to *880interrogatories, and cross motion by the plaintiff for leave to amend her answers to interrogatories, inter alia, are determined as follows:
In this matrimonial action, the defendant seeks leave to amend his answers to interrogatories pursuant to CPLR 3134 (c) so as to include a reference to a claimed equitable distribution in the plaintiff’s law degree. It is conceded that the plaintiff graduated from law school in 1976 and that she was admitted to the Bar in 1977. The parties were married in 1963. The defendant relies upon the recent Court of Appeals decision in O’Brien v O’Brien (66 NY2d 576 [1985]), in support of his motion.
In O’Brien, the Court of Appeals expressly held that a professional license (in that case, a medical license) acquired during marriage was a marital asset to which the other spouse may claim a distributive portion. The court, relying in part upon the language of Domestic Relations Law § 236 (B) (5) (d) (6), (9), stated "that an interest in a profession or professional career potential is marital property which may be represented by direct or indirect contributions of the non-title-holding spouse, including financial contributions and nonfinancial contributions made by caring for the home and family” (66 NY2d, at p 584).
The plaintiff herein argues that O’Brien is inapplicable to the case at bar since, in this case, she has never pursued a "private” law practice. "Instead, she has always opted to pursue a career of government, municipal or other agency service, at a fixed salary * * * Therefore, she has no private practice to evaluate or, alternatively, the value of her private practice is zero”. The plaintiff contends that "her license, as such, has no value under these circumstances”.
The court is not swayed by this argument.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit