New York Supreme Court April 17, 1986 (Aronson v. Rappaport)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-04-1986
OPINION OF THE COURT
Harold Baer, Jr., J.
Plaintiff, Aronson, seeks a declaration that he is entitled to continued residential occupancy of his loft, notwithstanding the "commercial” form of his expired lease. The original complaint, which was served on May 20, 1982, contained a cause of action for such declaratory relief based upon plaintiff’s allegation that the subject building constituted a de facto multiple dwelling. In January 1984, plaintiff moved to amend his complaint to include a claim that the subject building *273constitutes an "interim multiple dwelling”, pursuant to Multiple Dwelling Law article 7-C. By order, dated July 5, 1984, Justice Ascione granted plaintiff’s motion to amend his complaint.
Defendant, Rappaport, maintains that he is now entitled to summary judgment dismissing the cause of action which alleges that the premises are a de facto multiple dwelling. Defendant asserts that the rights and protections previously afforded to residential occupants of de facto multiple dwellings have been superseded by the enactment of article 7-C and the statutory rights and protections contained therein. Accordingly, defendant argues that there is no longer a viable cause of action for a declaration that premises are a de facto multiple dwelling.
Cases which have dealt with the issue of whether loft tenants can be afforded residential protection as occupants of de facto multiple dwellings subsequent to the enactment of Multiple Dwelling Law article 7-C have held both ways. Several older cases have held that the issue of whether tenants were protected as the occupants of a de facto multiple dwelling was properly before the court, notwithstanding the fact that Multiple Dwelling Law article 7-C by its terms took effect immediately and was to have retroactive application. (Thomas Loft Tenants Assn. v Lawrence Co., 117 Misc 2d 360 [Sup Ct 1982]; see, Haddad Corp. v Coco, index No. L&T 99085/81; Olsen v Hadway Realty Co., index No. 12019/81.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit