New York Supreme Court May 30, 1986 (Delaney v. Vardine Paratransit, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-05-1986

OPINION OF THE COURT

Lawrence E. Kahn J.

By motion returnable at the July 11, 1985 Albany County Special Term, counsel for defendant sought to withdraw as attorney of record upon the ground that there had been a termination of defendant’s insurance carrier’s duty to defend. This court denied the application, noting the absence of any proof with respect to the underlying obligation. The litigation has now been assigned to the Honorable Thomas E. Mercure, Justice, Supreme Court, pursuant to the individual assignment system. He has determined that the instant motion *398seeks renewal of the court’s prior determination, and as such, has referred the matter pursuant to CPLR 2221.

The underlying obligation seeks recovery for property damage alleged to have been caused by reason of defendant’s negligence. Counsel for defendant appeared in the litigation pursuant to the terms of defendant’s policy of insurance issued by the Hartford Insurance Company. Thereafter, during the pendency of the litigation, Hartford apparently, unilaterally, paid its policy limit of $5,000 to plaintiffs without regard to settlement of the litigation or any further exposure of its insured. It now asserts that its obligation to defend the ongoing litigation has been terminated by its unilateral act of payment. It premises this assertion upon the language of the policy which provides in part IV, A2 that "our payment of liability insurance limit ends our duty to defend or settle.”

11 NYCRR 60.1 establishes mandatory provisions for automobile liability insurance policies. Any conflicting language in the Hartford’s policy must be deemed a nullity and unenforceable. 11 NYCRR 60.1 (b), mandates defense of any suit and payment of certain costs accruing as the result thereof, including costs taxed against the insured, interest accruing after entry of judgment, etc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.