Rochester City Court December 15, 1986 (People v. Craft)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1986

OPINION OF THE COURT

Herman J. Walz, J.

On June 21, 1986, defendants participated in a demonstration in Cobbs Hill Park, a public park within the City of Rochester. They removed their shirts and uncovered their chests to protest what they view as sexist and repressive laws which permit men, but not women, to appear with bare chests in public places. The defendants were arrested and charged with violating Penal Law § 245.01, which imposes criminal sanctions on women for exposing their breasts below the top of the areola, in a public place.

Defendants move to dismiss the information on several constitutional grounds. Defendants contend that the statute violates their right to equal protection of the laws, and to freedom of expression. They also contend that the statute is void for vagueness, and that it deprives them of a fundamental human right under the US Constitution 9th Amendment. I conclude that the statute is constitutional. However, I also conclude that as applied to defendants’ conduct in this particular case the statute violates their rights to free expression as guaranteed by the Federal and State Constitutions. Thus, although the statute withstands these constitutional challenges on its face, as applied here it violates defendants’ rights. Although no evidentiary hearing was held on the motion to dismiss, the court considered the evidence adduced at the trial in determining the motion, on which decision had been reserved. The motion to dismiss the information is now granted.

I. EQUAL PROTECTION

Under the Penal Law only females can be convicted for exposure of the breasts. Indeed, the section was originally titled "Exposure of a female”. Curiously, the law originally prohibited the exposure of a female’s breasts, but not her genital area. The statute was directed at curbing the phenomenon of topless waitresses. Since it is clear from the cases that nudity by itself does not constitute lewdness (Matter of Excelsior Pictures Corp. v Regents of Univ.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.