Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Carbon County January 8, 1986, no. 85-0734 (Hoffman v. Shelby Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-01-1986

LAVELLE, P.J.,

This case raises the novel issue whether an insured may recover undeiinsured motorist benefits from his cam-*647er after he has settled his claim against the tortfeasor-third-party’s liability carrier for an amount less than the policy limits.

On July 1, 1985, plaintiff, James Frank Hoffman as administrator of the ' estate of Barbara Kay Hoffman (hereafter Hoffman) commenced this action against Shelby Mutual Insurance Company (hereafter Shelby Mutual) alleging that Shelby Mutual wrongfully denied underinsured motorist benefits due Hoffman.

Shelby Mutual responded by filing a preliminary objection in the nature of a demurrer to the complaint. After a careful review of the complaint and briefs submitted by the parties, and considering the able oral arguments of counsel, we agree with defendant that the complaint fails to state a cause of action and will sustain the demurrer.

FACTS OF THE CASE

Our standard of review on demurrer is well-settled. Accepting as true all facts pled in the complaint and reasonable inferences drawn therefrom, we may not dismiss the complaint unless the law will not permit the recovery sought by the plaintiff. Stein v. Richardson, 302 Pa. Super. 124, 448 A.2d 558 (1982).

Considered in this light, the complaint reveals the following facts:

On October 24, 1984, Hoffman’s decedent died as a result of injuries sustained when her car collided with a car driven by Scott Houser (hereafter Houser). Houser had liability insurance coverage with limits of $35,000. Hoffman settled the death claims against Houser for $32,000, giving Houser and his insurance company a joint tortfeasor’s release.

*648After the settlement, Hoffman demanded $15,000 from Shelby Mutual on the basis of the underinsured motorist provisions of the decedent’s own automobile insurance policy.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.