Court of Appeals of Arizona June 11, 1986, No. 2 CA-CIV 5694 (T.H. Properties v. Sunshine Auto Rental, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-06-1986

HOWARD, Presiding Judge.

This is an appeal of a forcible entry and detainer action wherein the trial court granted the landlord possession and awarded the sum of $2,099 for unpaid taxes, and $3,142.50 for unpaid rent.

The facts disclose that on August 10, 1982, T.H. Properties’ (TH) predecessor in interest, S & J Investments (S & J) leased the premises at issue to Sunshine Auto Rental, Inc. (Sunshine). According to the terms of the lease Sunshine was to pay monthly rent in the sum of $3,000 plus rental taxes and the real property taxes. Sunshine failed to pay the Maricopa County real estate taxes due on October 22, 1984, and failed to pay the rent due on November 1, 1984. On November 2, S & J gave written notice of default to Sunshine stating that it had three days to cure the defaults. On November 6, S & J received a check from Sunshine in an amount sufficient to pay the taxes and rent. S & J presented the check to Sunshine’s bank which refused to honor it. The bank teller wrote on the back of the check: “Funds not available at this time. 11-6-84.”

On November 9, S & J delivered written notice to Sunshine, in accordance with the lease and prior notice of default, that the lease was terminated. In addition, the notice demanded possession of the premises as well as payment of the overdue rent and taxes.

On November 12, several days after the termination and demand for payment, Sunshine delivered a cashier’s check in the amount demanded for overdue rent and taxes to the office of S & J. S & J and its successor in interest, TH, retained the check for monies demanded in the November 9 termination letter, but did not negotiate it immediately. Neither S & J nor TH had any intention of reinstating the lease.

At the close of trial, Sunshine moved for a directed verdict contending that TH had failed to present evidence of ownership. TH was granted permission by the court to reopen its case to put the lease assignment into evidence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.