Indiana Court of Appeals April 29, 1986, No. 1-1185A292 (State v. Bowen)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-04-1986

NEAL, Judge.

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

The State of Indiana (State) brings an interlocutory appeal from an order entered by the Daviess Circuit Court suppressing a statement made by defendant-appellee, Timothy O. Bowen (Bowen).

We reverse.

*1024STATEMENT OF THE FACTS

The undisputed facts are as follows. Da-viess County police officers were notified that Melvin and Evadean Bainter, husband and wife, had been stabbed in their mobile home'in the early morning of November 5, 1984. At the hospital, Evadean told the officers that her son, Bowen, had stabbed them. Officers then went to the mobile home, found Bowen still there, and asked him to come out to talk to them about the stabbing. Bowen refused, lectured the officers at length on arrest procedure, and demanded a warrant. He also demanded to see a judge, but he was told no judge was available. However, the officers told him if he wanted to talk to a lawyer, one would be appointed. There is some evidence that he did wish to talk to a lawyer. During the 45 minute standoff, conversation consisted only of trying to get Bowen to come out to talk about the stabbing. During that time the officers learned by radio that Melvin had died, but they decided not to tell Bowen lest such information provoke a violent reaction.

Finally, after an officer had slipped into the mobile home, Bowen was captured, placed under arrest, and handcuffed. No Miranda warnings were given to him, nor was he interrogated at this point. However, in the mobile home Bowen spontaneously stated that Evadean, in the past, had cut him with a razor, and he exhibited his scar to the officers. Bowen also said that he had been shot that morning by a BB or pellet gun by Melvin, and he exhibited to the officer a tiny wound covered by a smudge of dried blood.

Upon Bowen's request that a doctor look at his wound, he was taken to the same hospital where Melvin and Evadean had been taken.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.