Indiana Court of Appeals June 9, 1986, No. 4-885A231 (Guess v. Weiss)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-06-1986

CONOVER, Judge.

Richard Guess (Guess), defendant below, appeals a breach of contract judgment and award of damages and attorney fees.

We reverse.

ISSUES

Guess asserts six issues for review. Because we reverse we discuss only the first issue:

1. Whether jury trial was improperly denied?

FACTS

Richard and Carol Guess sold a building in Gary, Indiana, to Lawrence and Marlene Weiss (Weiss). Guess financed the sale by taking back a $25,000 note and mortgage from Weiss. The building had a flat roof which Guess agreed to have repaired.

Guess had the roof repaired but it continued to leak after Weiss took possession of the building. Weiss had the roof repaired and sued Guess.

Weiss sought damages for breach of contract and fraud. He prayed for set-off from the balance owed on the note.

Guess answered and made timely demand for a jury trial. (R. 20). However, the cause was set for bench trial.

On the day set for trial, the court found Guess had waived the right to jury trial. The jury was dismissed. Guess objected to dismissal of the jury, noting his earlier jury demand. The court proceeded with a bench trial. Guess moved for findings of fact and conclusions of law which motion was granted.

DISCUSSION AND DECISION

Guess asserts the trial court erred when it denied his demand for a jury trial.

The right to trial by jury is preserved by our Indiana Constitution, Art. 1, § 20.1 Ind. Rules of Procedure, Trial Rules 38(B)2 and 39(A) 3 provide the means by which this right is asserted.

*814It is uncontested (a) Guess timely made his demand for jury trial, and (b) the issues were triable by jury as of right. The parties did not consent to trial by the court under Trial Rule 39(A)(1) nor did Guess waive the right to trial by jury under Trial Rule 38(D).4

Weiss contends Guess waived the right to trial by jury.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.