Ohio Supreme Court December 19, 1986, No. 86-631 (Buckeye Candy & Tobacco Co. v. Limbach)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-12-1986

Per Curiam.

The issues presented in this appeal are: (1) whether the September 25, 1985 amendment of R.C. 5717.02 applies to the case at bar, and (2) if it does not apply, whether the failure to include the certificate of determination in a notice of appeal to the Board of Tax Appeals is a jurisdictional defect in pre-amendment cases. For the reasons which follow, we find that the September 25, 1985 amendment does not apply to the case at bar, and that failure to include the copy of the Tax Commissioner’s final determination was a defect which deprived the Board of Tax Appeals of jurisdiction.

At the time appellant filed his notice of appeal, and for over nine months thereafter, R.C. 5717.02 provided in part:

* * The notice of appeal shall have attached thereto and incorporated therein by reference a true copy of the notice sent by the commissioner or director to the taxpayer or enterprise of the final determination complained of, and shall also specify the errors therein complained of.”

An amendment of this section, effective September 25, 1985, added:

*41“but failure to attach a copy of such notice and incorporate it by reference in the notice of appeal does not invalidate the appeal.”

The pre-amendment requirement of R.C. 5717.02 of attaching the commissioner’s finding to notices of appeal has long been held to be jurisdictional, the failure to satisfy which necessitates dismissal. Hanson Machinery Co. v. Limbach (1986), 22 Ohio St. 3d 209, 210, citing Kinsman Square Drug Co. v. Evatt (1945), 145 Ohio St. 52 [30 O.O. 279]; American Restaurant & Lunch Co. v. Glander (1946), 147 Ohio St. 147 [34 O.O. 8]; and Hafner & Sons v. Lindley (1979), 58 Ohio St. 2d 130, 131 [12 O.O.3d 127]. See, also, Wills Trucking, Inc. v. Limbach (1986), 24 Ohio St. 3d 166.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.