Court of Appeals of Oregon December 17, 1986, A8601-00044; CA A39249 (Farley v. Farmers Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-12-1986

lead-opinion

VAN HOOMISSEN, J.

This is an action for a declaratory judgment. Plaintiff sought a declaration that Farmers Insurance Company (Farmers) owed her a duty to provide personal injury protection (PIP) benefits under the insurance contract. She also sought a money judgment as supplementary relief for her unreimbursed medical expenses. There are no issues of fact. The trial court granted Farmer’s, and denied plaintiffs, motion for summary judgment as a matter of law. She appeals. The issue is whether underinsured motorist benefits are “collateral benefits” within the contemplation of ORS 743.810(1)(e). The trial court concluded that they are. We reverse.

In October, 1985, plaintiff, a pedestrian, was injured when she was hit by a car driven by Farmers’ insured. She incurred more than $10,000 in medical expenses, $5,000 of which was paid under the PIP provisions of her own insurance contract, which provides only the $5,000 statutory minimum PIP coverage. Her contract also includes $300,000 underinsured motorist coverage. Farmers’ contract with its insured provides $10,000 in PIP coverage. Farmers refused to pay the unpaid balance of plaintiffs medical expenses remaining after her own PIP coverage was exhausted. This action ensued.

Farmers based its denial on ORS 743.810. That statute provides, in relevant part:

“(1) The personal injury protection benefits with respect to:

<<* * * * *

“(e) Pedestrians injured by the insured motor vehicle, other than the insured and members of his family residing in the same household, shall be excess over any other collateral benefits to which the injured party is entitled, including but not limited to insurance benefits, governmental benefits or gratuitous benefits.” (Emphasis supplied.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.