Louisiana Court of Appeal April 11, 1986, No. CA-4631 (Marechal v. Louisiana State Racing Commission)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-04-1986
ARMSTRONG, Judge.
Petitioner, Merlin Marechal, filed a petition for injunction seeking to enjoin the defendant, Louisiana State Racing Commission (“Commission”), from enforcing the Commission’s order suspending him for a period of three years and fining him $2,000.1 The matter came for trial on April 9, 1983 but was submitted on the record and continued for submission of briefs. On June 27, 1985 judgment was entered in favor of petitioner and a preliminary injunction was issued enjoining the Commission from effecting the suspension of petitioner’s license to engage in his lawful occupation as an owner/trainer of thoroughbred horses. It is from this judgment that the Commission appeals. We reverse.
The record reflects that on November 10, 1983 members of the Racing Commission’s State Police Racing Investigations Unit conducted a warrantless administrative search of the petitioner’s barn at Jefferson Downs and found a suitcase containing articles prohibited by the Rules of Racing. It appears that although the suitcase was found at Jefferson Downs, it was not searched until the following day at state police headquarters. Neither the search of the barn nor the search of the suitcase was specifically authorized by either the Commission or the race track stewards.
A hearing on charges that petitioner had violated race track rules was held by the stewards on December 14, 1983. The petitioner was found to have violated the rules and was fined $200. Petitioner did not appeal this decision. The matter was then referred to the Commission who in turn suspended plaintiff for three years and fined him $2,000.
In his petition for injunction, petitioner argued that the warrantless searches of the barn and suitcase were unconstitutional and, therefore, that the Commission should not have considered the evidence seized in the searches.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit